Another notable difference between the Gospels of Matthew and Luke concerns what happened to Mary, Joseph, and Jesus after his birth. Although both Gospels place Jesus’ birth in Bethlehem and his childhood in Nazareth, they describe the family’s movements differently.
In Matthew’s Gospel, the family’s journey takes an unexpected turn. After Jesus is born in Bethlehem, the Magi visit him and bring gifts. Later, Joseph is warned in a dream to take Mary and Jesus to Egypt because King Herod intends to kill the child (Matthew 2:13–15). Herod subsequently orders the killing of male children in Bethlehem and its surrounding region who are two years old or younger. The family remains in Egypt until Herod’s death. Only then does Joseph bring them back to Israel. After learning that Herod’s son Archelaus rules Judea, Joseph is warned in another dream and settles with his family in Nazareth, in Galilee (Matthew 2:19–23).
Luke presents a different sequence of events. Following Jesus’ birth, Mary and Joseph take him to Jerusalem to fulfil the requirements of the Law, including the purification rites and the presentation of the firstborn (Luke 2:22–24). After completing everything required by the Law of the Lord, they return to Galilee, to their own town of Nazareth (Luke 2:39). Luke does not mention the visit of the Magi, Herod’s massacre of the children, the family’s escape to Egypt, or their stay there.
This raises an important question: if the family fled to Egypt and remained there until Herod’s death, how does Luke’s account of their return to Nazareth fit into the same timeline?
One possible explanation is that Matthew and Luke selected different events for their narratives. Luke may have omitted the flight to Egypt because it was not part of the story he chose to tell. Likewise, Matthew may have omitted Luke’s detailed account of the purification rites and the family’s visit to Jerusalem. Some readers understand Luke’s description of the return to Nazareth as a summary that does not mention every intervening event. However, Luke’s wording presents the return as following the completion of the required rites, while Matthew describes a journey to Egypt before the family eventually settles in Nazareth.
Therefore, the two accounts differ in the sequence and details they provide about Jesus’ early childhood. Whether these differences can be reconciled through an unstated timeline or reflect distinct narrative traditions remains a matter of interpretation. What is clear is that Matthew and Luke do not provide the same account of the family’s movements after Jesus’ birth.
Leave a Reply